Subscribe to
Posts [Atom]

Captain's Log : A Pirate Story: Dane

Saturday, July 29, 2006

Dane



Don't get me wrong, I'm a Dane Cook fan, I really am. He appeals to a large, young audience because his jokes are contemporary and easily related to. And, like a lot of comedians before him a large portion of his success comes not from the actual jokes but from his unique delivery. However, the only thing that has kept him from being my favorite comedian is that a lot of his jokes albeit explosively delivered are ridiculous quips having nothing to do with anything. Also, you could be a gradeschool dropout and find Cook funny, which just isn't my style and is the same reason Family Guy never really appealed to me.

But now comes the allegation that Dane Cook has blatantly stolen jokes from the afore-posted-about Louis C.K., something that knocks him down a few pegs on my all-time comedian list. It may be true that comedians share jokes often and that these days there is little in the way of originality in the world of comedy. However, given THIS PIECE OF INVESTIGATION, I am a little dissapointed. It's an mp3 of 3 consecutive jokes, one told by CK, followed by the VERY SIMILAR jokes of Dane. Again, Dane's delivery makes them more appealing to today's audiences, which I sort of agree with. The tracks are from a 2001 CK album and a 2005 Cook album. Jeez.

My favorite comedians are still David Cross, Chris Rock, George Carlin, and perhaps Marc Maron.

2 Comments:

At 11:41 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I wasn't all that convinced by that clip. I mean, for one thing, both those guys are pretty prolific in terms of the number of topics they can cover in a set, and neither one still has to rely on material that is several years old like many comedians out there do. So the fact that they have touched on the same topic three different times is not strong evidence of plagiarism. On top of that, the language is not all that similar (not to mention that the audio has been edited to make them sound more similar than they actually are). Finally, all three of those jokes are pretty obvious. Who hasn't had the idea to name your kid something weird? Who hasn't had an itchy asshole? I have one right now.

 
At 6:35 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

You mean your favorite comedians other than Larry the Cable Guy...?

 

Post a Comment

<< Home